The Professionals. Visions of Order. What Is To Be Done. In Great Britain, North America and Western Europe, the 's saw new theories and styles of social control which seemed to undermine the whole basis of the established system. Such slogans as 'decarceration' and 'division' radically changed the dominance of the prison, the power of professionals and the crime-control system itself. Stanley Cohen traces the historical roots of these apparent changes and reforms, demonstrates in detail their often paradoxical results and speculates on the whole future of social control in Western societies.
He has produced an entirely original synthesis of the original literature as well as an introductory guide to the major theoreticians of social control, such as David Rothman and Michael Foucault. This is not just a book for the specialist in criminology, social problems and the sociology of deviance but raises a whole range of issues of much wider interest to the social sciences.
A concluding chapter on the practical and policy implications of the analysis is of special relevance to social workers and other practitioners. This is an indispensable book for anyone who wants to make sense of the bewildering recent shifts in ideology and policy towards crime - and to understand the broader sociological implications of the study of social control.
Subjects Social control. Crime prevention. Bibliographic information. Publication date Note Includes bibliographical references and index. Browse related items Start at call number: HM However, it could be countered that delinquents can be conscious of how deviant acts might provide an access to rewards and status within their group without individually inverting mainstream values every time they deviate.
Cohen specifically says that this is a phenomenon relating to "working-class boys" and yet makes very few links between his theory and either social class or gender. Why do working-class boys particularly struggle to attain status at school or in mainstream society? Other sociologists, like Paul Willis, attempt to address that question, but Cohen does not. Furthermore, why boys?
Finally, a point in Cohen's favour is that he does successfully develop Merton's strain theory to provide an explanation for non-utilitarian crimes. Therefore, taken together, Merton and Cohen offer a functionalist explanation for a wide range of deviant behaviour.
Company Reg no: VAT reg no Main menu. Subjects Shop Courses Live Jobs board. The interaction between network diversity and chronic stress also did not achieve statistical significance, indicating that social network diversity had the same impact on cold susceptibility for both those with and without a chronic stressor.
Those with low levels of social participation were more likely to be smokers and less likely to exercise Cohen et al. Both of these health practices were also associated with susceptibility to colds, with smokers and those getting less exercise at greater risk. However, these health practices could explain only a small fraction of the relation between network diversity and susceptibility to infectious illness. Although higher levels of epinephrine and norepinephrine were associated with greater risk for developing a cold, neither of these hormones or cortisol was associated with the social network index.
Hence, neither could operate as pathways linking network diversity to illness susceptibility. Also, our measure of immune function, natural killer cell cytotoxicity, was not associated with either network diversity or cold risk. The "Big Five" personality factors are thought to represent the basic structure of personality e. The factors are commonly described as introversion-extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, emotional stability, and openness. We found that only introversion-extraversion was associated with susceptibility to colds.
However, the relation between network diversity and colds occurred above and beyond independent of the association of introversion and colds. This study demonstrated that social isolation constitutes a major risk factor for the development of illness.
Volunteers who were relatively socially isolated relationships were 4. Although relative isolation relationships accounted for most of the effect, the association was graded with persons with moderate numbers of social roles receiving some benefit.
This suggests that it is something about occupying a variety of social roles e. How this occurs is not clear, although the present study suggests that it is not likely to be through a stress-buffering mechanism.
First, the association of social network diversity and illness susceptibility was independent of the increased risk for colds found among those experiencing chronic stressful events. Second, we found no evidence for an interaction between social participation and chronic stress in predicting cold susceptibility. That is, the presence of an enduring stressor increased illness risk for volunteers across the spectrum of social network diversity.
We found that the relation between network diversity and susceptibility to the common cold was independent of network size. However, we cannot be sure that this relation is independent of other network features that might correlate with diversity, such as network density, weak ties, and structural holes see discussion in Brissette et al. In the case of density, there is some evidence that low density social networks are associated with better mental health Hirsch, ; Both concepts should covary with diversity and both have known effects that could contribute to health status and maintenance.
Unfortunately, there are no existing data on the association between these concepts and network diversity, nor any evidence in regard to whether these concepts have implications for health. However, further work in this area can only give us a better understanding of how networks influence our health. What can account for the relations between social participation, and susceptibility to infectious illness? Earlier, we raised the possibility that this association might be mediated by effects of social diversity on either health practices or on the function of the endocrine and immune systems.
People with diverse social networks are thought to be subject to more social controls and engage in improved health practices Cohen, In addition, possessing a diverse social network is thought to promote emotional regulation and influence the circulating levels of hormones capable of altering immune function. However, when we measured these potential pathways, none could account for the relations we found. In the case of health practices, all five of the measures operated as risk factors for illness.
Smokers, those abstaining from alcohol, those with poor sleep efficiency, and those with few days of exercise were at greater risk for developing colds Cohen et al. However, health practices could account for only a small part of the relations between the social environment and host resistance. Because the health practice measures were all related to susceptibility in the expected manner, we are confident in the accuracy of our assessments.
As a consequence, it seems unlikely that these health practices play a major role in linking social environments to resistance to infectious illness. Although we assessed the health practices that we thought would be most likely to provide a pathway, it is possible that other practices such as caffeine intake, use of mouth wash, or regular hand washing, might link social participation to illness susceptibility. Those individuals with elevated levels of circulating epinephrine and norepinephrine were at greater risks for developing colds.
Again, however, levels of these hormones did not provide any additional explanation of the relation between social diversity and colds. To our surprise, these hormones were not associated with the social participation measures. In our current work, we are attempting to get better background levels by measuring hormones several times during the weeks before volunteers report for quarantine.
This is a case where obtaining reliable measurements multiple measures at appropriate points in time is essential. We chose natural killer cell activity as our primary marker of immune function for two reasons.
First, natural killer cells are surveillance cells that identify infected and otherwise altered cells and kill them. In theory, higher levels of natural killer cell activity should help limit infection and hence prevent illness. However, NK activity did not operate as a pathway linking stress or social participation to illness susceptibility in our study.
In theory, NK activity in the respiratory track might be a protective mechanism against respiratory infections. It is also possible the NK activity in the blood might make a difference, but that the ability of the immune system to compensate for deficits in single subsystems obscures any relation. At any rate, we found no evidence for immune mediation of the relations between stress and infectious illness or social participation and infectious disease.
Again, we think that this may be attributable to problems in measurement. In sum, our data are consistent with theories suggesting that occupying diverse social roles is beneficial to health. The data also support the notion that the more roles one holds the better Marks, ; Sieber, ; Thoits, , although the costs of being isolated are greater than one would expect from a purely graded relationship.
The social network measures used in studies of health outcomes probably appear rather primitive compared to those involved in formal social network analysis readers of this journal. A primary reason that relatively simple measures are used is that studies of health outcomes typically involve large samples and include multiple questionnaires or interview measures, pushing the envelope in respect to demands on subjects.
For these types of studies, concise instruments are at a premium and intensive measurement is reserved for the rare cases in which the investigator is convinced that the time is worth the potential payoff.
Even so, the consistent demonstrated importance of social integration measures in health may generate a greater interest in using more elaborate quantitative measurement of social networks for these types of studies. Quantitative approaches would be especially helpful to the extent that they can be used to distinguish between alternative theories of how social integration influences health. Brissette, I.
Cohen, S. Measuring social integration and social networks. Cohen, L. Gottlieb Eds. NY: Oxford Press. Berkman, L.
The role of social relations in health promotion. Psychosomatic Medicine, 57, Burt, R. Personality correlates of structural holes. Social Networks, 20, Psychosocial models of the role of social support in the etiology of physical disease. Health Psychology, 7, Social ties and susceptibility to the common cold. Journal of the American Medical Association, , Types of stressors that increase susceptibility to the common cold. Health Psychology, 17, Social relationships and health.
Gottlieb eds. New York: Oxford Press. Health psychology: Psychological factors and physical disease from the perspective of human psychonueroimmunology. Annual Review of Psychology, 47, Stress and infectious disease in humans.
Psychological Bulletin, , Stress, social support and the buffering hypothesis. Psychological Bulletin, 98, Faris, R. Cultural isolation and the schizophrenic personality. American Journal of Sociology, 40, Glaser, R. Stress-induced immunomodulation: Implication for infectious disease? Goldberg, L. The development of markers for the Big-Five factor structure.
0コメント